Journal · Italy · Guide
Sicily or Sardinia: which Italian island is for you?
Two great islands, two very different temperaments. One is all temples, volcano and Baroque stone; the other is granite, white sand and water so clear it looks unreal. Here is how we help our guests choose, and why some of them choose both.
Sicily or Sardinia? It is one of the questions we are asked most often, and the short answer is simpler than people expect. Choose Sicily for culture, history, food and drama. Choose Sardinia for beaches, sea and barefoot glamour.
Both are large, both are beautiful, and both feel only loosely attached to the mainland. But they ask different things of you. Sicily wants you curious and hungry, ready for an amphitheatre in the morning and a long lunch on the slopes of a volcano. Sardinia wants you in the water by ten and on a boat by noon. Below, we set out the differences, then explain how we would plan an Italian island holiday that takes in both.
Sicily vs Sardinia, side by side
| Sicily | Sardinia | |
|---|---|---|
| The feel | Theatrical and layered, Italy at full volume | Relaxed, with a wilder edge |
| Beaches | Good coves and lidos, but not the main event | Among the finest in the Mediterranean |
| Food & wine | Street food, pastry, Etna and Nero d’Avola wines | Seafood, pecorino, roast suckling pig, Vermentino and Cannonau |
| Culture & history | Greek temples and theatres, Norman churches, Baroque towns | Bronze Age nuraghi and quiet hill villages |
| Luxury style | Grand hotels on clifftops, restored palazzi and country estates | Beach resorts, private villas and superyachts |
| Getting around | Larger and busier; a private driver makes all the difference | Easier roads, and the best of it is reached by boat |
| Best for | Food lovers, first-timers to Italy, culture seekers | Beach lovers, families, sailors, couples who want to switch off |
Sicily: an island of theatre
Start in Taormina, perched on its cliff above the Ionian Sea. It has drawn travellers since the days of the Grand Tour, and it is easy to see why. The main street is lined with palazzi and small churches, the bougainvillea spills over every wall, and below the town the coast curls away in a series of rocky bays.
The great set piece is the Teatro Antico, the ancient theatre founded by the Greeks and later rebuilt by the Romans. Sit on the stone tiers and look out past the ruined stage: the sea on one side, and on the other, on a clear day, the long smoking shoulder of Etna. Few views in Italy are so carefully composed, and this one is more than two thousand years old.
Mount Etna
Mount Etna is Europe’s most active volcano, and it dominates eastern Sicily in every sense. Go up with a qualified guide and you walk across lunar fields of black lava and past craters from recent eruptions, with the sea far below. How high you can safely go depends on the mountain’s mood, so plans are always flexible.
Then come down for lunch. The volcanic soils on Etna’s lower slopes produce some of Italy’s most exciting wines, mineral reds from Nerello Mascalese and crisp whites from Carricante, and a long lunch at a family winery is one of the great Sicilian afternoons.
The Baroque south-east and Ortigia
After the earthquake of 1693, the towns of the south-east were rebuilt in an exuberant late Baroque style, and they now sit together on UNESCO’s World Heritage list. Noto is the most elegant, its honey-coloured stone glowing at dusk. Ragusa tumbles down its ridge, and Modica is known as much for its grainy, old-fashioned chocolate as for its churches.
Nearby is Ortigia, the small island at the heart of ancient Syracuse. Once one of the most powerful cities of the Greek world, it is now a lovely maze of limestone lanes, sea walls and fish market stalls, with a cathedral built around the columns of a Greek temple.
Eating in Sicily
Sicily is, quite simply, one of the best places to eat in Europe. There are arancini, golden and crisp, eaten warm from a paper bag. There is granita, almond or lemon or coffee, eaten for breakfast with a soft brioche in the heat of summer. And there are cannoli, filled with fresh ricotta only when you order them, as they should be. Drink Etna wines in the east and Nero d’Avola, the island’s great red grape, everywhere else. For luxury Sicily at its most indulgent, this is where much of the pleasure lies.
Sardinia: sea, granite and light
Sardinia’s fame rests on its coast, and above all on the Costa Smeralda in the north-east. Developed from the 1960s by the Aga Khan and his partners, this stretch of granite headlands and coves became the summer address of Europe’s jet set, and it still is. Porto Cervo is its harbour, full of yachts in high summer, with smart boutiques and a lively evening scene. The hotels are low-slung and discreet, and the style is unmistakable: linen, bare feet and a very good bottle of rosé.
Just offshore lies the La Maddalena archipelago, a national park of granite islands scattered across water of almost absurd clarity. It is best seen by boat. A day on a crewed yacht here, anchoring off empty coves and swimming in water that shades from turquoise to deep blue, is the reason many of our guests come to Sardinia in the first place.
Gallura and the interior
Drive inland and the landscape changes quickly. Gallura is a country of wind-carved granite, cork oak forests and small stone villages, and it produces Vermentino di Gallura, a fresh, saline white wine that tastes exactly right with a plate of seafood by the sea. A day visiting an estate here, with lunch among the vines, makes a fine contrast to the beach.
Beaches, and the island beyond the glamour
If the question is Sardinia or Sicily for beaches, the answer is Sardinia, without much hesitation. Its long white beaches and very clear water rival anywhere in the Mediterranean, and outside August many of them are blissfully quiet.
And there is a quieter, wilder Sardinia beyond the Costa Smeralda. Bronze Age stone towers called nuraghi dot the countryside, the mountain villages keep their own traditions, and parts of the interior are famous for the long lives of their inhabitants. It is, fittingly, one of the world’s original Blue Zones.
Sicily or Sardinia: who should pick which?
- Couples. For romance with substance, Sicily: a terrace in Taormina, dinners in Ortigia, the Baroque towns at dusk. For romance that means doing very little, beautifully, Sardinia.
- Families. Sardinia, usually. Shallow, clear water, easy boat days and resorts that welcome children make it a gentler holiday for all ages.
- Food lovers. Sicily, clearly. Few places in Italy offer such range, from street food to winery lunches.
- Beach lovers. Sardinia. Sicily has lovely spots, but the Sardinian coast is in a different league.
- First-timers to Italy’s islands. Sicily gives you more of Italy’s history in a single trip. If you have already seen Rome, Florence or Tuscany, you might begin in Siena (our two days in Siena is a good start) and finish on Sardinia’s beaches instead.
Or do both: ten days across two islands
For guests who cannot choose, we often suggest a journey that takes in both. The two islands are closer than most people imagine, and a short private flight from Catania to Olbia takes about an hour. Here is how we would plan it.
Days 1–5
Sicily, based in Taormina
- Around five nights in a hotel or villa above the sea
- Mount Etna with a volcanologist guide, followed by lunch at a winery on its slopes
- A private day in Ortigia and Noto, with time for granita and the Baroque
- A day on a crewed yacht along the coast below Taormina
- An after-hours visit to the Teatro Antico, when the crowds have gone
Days 6–10
Sardinia, on the Costa Smeralda
- A private flight from Catania to Olbia, roughly an hour
- Around five nights on the Costa Smeralda, in a beach hotel or private villa
- A yacht day in the La Maddalena archipelago
- A day in Gallura, with lunch and tasting at a Vermentino estate
- Unhurried beach days, and an evening in Porto Cervo
The order matters. Sicily first, while you have the energy for sightseeing; Sardinia second, when all you want is the sea.
When to go
The best months for both islands are late May to June and September. The sea is warm, the light is soft and the roads and beaches are calmer than in high summer. July and August are glorious but busy, especially on the Costa Smeralda. Whenever you travel, the best villas and yachts are booked well in advance, so we recommend holding them several months ahead.
Whichever island you choose, or both, we will shape the journey around how you like to travel. Tell us your dates and we will take care of the rest.
Frequently asked questions
Is Sicily or Sardinia better for a first visit?
Sicily is usually the better first visit if you love history, architecture and food. Sardinia suits travellers whose priority is beaches, swimming and time on the water.
Which has better beaches, Sicily or Sardinia?
Sardinia has the better beaches, with long stretches of white sand and exceptionally clear water, particularly on the Costa Smeralda and around the La Maddalena archipelago.
Can you visit Sicily and Sardinia in one trip?
Yes. A private flight from Catania to Olbia takes roughly an hour, so ten days split between the two islands works well.
What is the best time to visit Sicily and Sardinia?
Late May to June and September are the best months for both islands, with warm seas and fewer crowds than in July and August.
Is Sardinia good for families?
Sardinia is very good for families, thanks to its shallow, clear water, easy boat days and family-friendly beach hotels.